The Gloom Map Depository
Goto the Review List Chat with us online at irc.edgeirc.net in #gloom (With mIRC)
GMD Verdict  

Review of Gloomy Mines 2
"mines-1 with a large backway and poor rock brushwork"
-
Map Name   Gloomy Mines 2 (mines-2.bsp)
Map Author   Gorgon
Download   mines-2.zip (0.7mb)
 
Reviewer   Echon
Reviewed on   Sun Jun 20 05:32:04 2004

Everybody knows, and most adore, the very famous gloom map mines-1. A very popular gloom map, known for it's get-the-center-or-lose tactical mindset. The author of this map likes it enough to put a special thanks and a cheesy smile in the map name message!

As you enter the map you're introduced to the same basic style the original gave you, duh. You see the lava and the platforms, the crates, the generically bevelled wall curtains, and the mine textures that were also scattered across the layout of the original. You already know you can't expect originality, but that's fine as long as it plays well, if not better than the original.

One of the things that really bugs me in this map is the brushwork. The bevelled side-skirts aren't done "right", bent around corners weird, or just placed oddly. Some of the lights are actually just 4x4 formations of small lights, the rest are completely identical, with exception to their color (which was either blue, green or orange). The rock and stone is placed in almost purely square form. It almost appears as if the author was just randomly rotating and placing brushes against each other in an attempt to make it look 'stone-ish'. There are attempted blast marks that almost resemble an asterisk. A star formation is made and lava is placed below it, or sky placed above it, to resemble the aftermath of a large explosion, cutting through the terrain.

Lighting also has issues. Some of the lights are generic entity spot lights, which are not setup to fade off well, making "spots". Also, as mentioned above, there wasn't much variety to color or to design. They were all either cube lights, or there was lava emitting below.

Texturing was another kick to the teeth. It's funny when you enter the pure-stone alien base only to find that the doorway leading in is made of the generic metal texture. The wall around the doorway, inside the rock-carved alien base, has the metal texture as well! You also find random support columns, built into the rock wall formation, and metal ledges. The same silly cube lights are littered in the rock room, but those were in the original alien base and rock backway, so I will let that slide. There's also parts where there should be a metal texture, and you have a flat rock surface.

The layout of the map looks rather ridiculous from out of and above the map. You have a very long and vent-like passage above it all. Not sure what can access it, but it almost looks like fly/grapple classes are the only ones that can get in it easily. Everything seems to connect to everything else at least twice. This map has more holes in it than swiss cheese. The human start base is only accessable through an easily defended ladder, I smell the rechid stench of choke point just thinking about it.

In conclusion, and to sum this all up, the brush work could use a lot of work, the lighting could use smoothing and originality, and the layout is insanely riddled with passageways. It might play well, but if one team is in danger, it has about 5 or 6 dozen options for places to run through, and to run to. This also makes it difficult to defend, since the opponent can come from any given direction. You'll have fun playing this map if you like changing bases every 10 minutes.


User comments:
orly - Echon
o - rly
fuk u echon - Gorgon
^^^^^^ Doesn't know what he's talking about. - niaP .tgS
I'd have to agree with Echon on most of what he said about the map.It does ... - D347H [more]
Big, Dark and Confusing. Don't map ever again, get some skill and go to h... - Ranger [more]
Its a decent change, agreeing with D347H-- I could probably map mines-3 bett... - Kain [more]
i think it sucks! - saig
you're all gay - Jimmy
who the fuck are you dipshit - saig-again
Crap. Try a more simple aproach. They usually work better than a huge maze.. - Jose
http://www.ringtones-dir.com/download/ download ringtones. nokia ... - free ringtones [more]
http://www.ringtones-dir.com/get/ ringtones site. Download rington... - ringtones free [more]

Your name:

Comment on this review:

Average rating for Gloomy Mines 2: 3.8/10

Rate-O-Map™

Total: 16 ratings
 
Textures
Cube Cube

Comment: Texturing was decent, though the author loses a couple cubes for the various texture misalignments and improper usage.

Layout
Cube Cube

Comment: The randomly long nearly inaccessible upper vent-like thing is silly. It bridged across the entire map, from alien base to backway, connecting to many other rooms along the way.

Creativity
Cube Cube Cube

Comment: Creativity is not expected to be very high, considering it's a mock up of an existing map. The author did a good job of keeping close to the same style.

Overall
Cube

Comment: My biggest complaint is brushwork. Star-shaped holes representing blast marks, blocky rock formations and hallways, and repetitive lights tend to get annoying.
This review has been read 1462 times. The Gloom Map Depository is copyright Team GMD. Quake2 is a registered trademark of Id Software. Gloom is copyright Team Reaction. The review script is copyright R1CH.